Illegal Immigration Statistics
In Response to the people calling this batch fo statistics about immigration false or not truly sourced, you are almost right.
The sources actual vary and my research has found the source of most of these illegal immigration statistics. It does turn out though that most of this IS TRUE according to federal testimony.
Jobs American’s wont do? lies, corrupt liars telling lies.
More than 43% of all Food Stamps issued are to illegal aliens.
More than 41% of all unemployment checks issued in the United States are to illegal aliens.
For the leftist pro-criminal amnesty crowd here is a small samle of what is in store for your childrens future. Keep in mind that during the 1986 Amnesty push the number of border crossing increased 1000%. So these are just very low ideas of actual facts about immigration and immigrant criminals that you can expect for your children to deal with.
This is what a YES vote for cloture today represents for the future of your children’s country.
This is the result of 3rd world disregard for the laws and rules being laid down in a first world United States.
These are facts, I would like to see “pro immigration” arguments and excuses to explain some of this. This is the country destorying path of today’s “amnesty for criminals”.
This is what the “poor family just trying to work” is really doing to our once great nation.
These are the topics that thos ein congress ignore to win votes and secure their future election totals.
From the 2006 (lst Qtr) INS/FBI Statistical Report - link
“12 Americans are murdered every day by illegal aliens. (that’s more than 21,900 murders by illegal aliens since September 11, 2001)
13 people per day are killed by illegal immigrants who drive under the influence of drugs or alcohol. An additional 4,745 premature deaths per year.
62% of all “undocumented immigrants” in the United States are working for cash and not paying taxes, predominantly illegal aliens, working without a green card.
95% of warrants for murder in Los Angeles are for illegal aliens.
83% of warrants for murder in Phoenix are for illegal aliens.
86% of warrants for murder in Albuquerque are for illegal aliens.
75% of people on the most wanted list in Los Angeles, Phoenix, and Albuquerque are illegal aliens.
More than 380,000 “anchor babies” born in the United States in 2005 were to parents who are illegal aliens; making those 380,000 babies automatically U.S. citizens. 97.2% of all costs incurred from those births were paid by the American taxpayer.
More than 66% of all births in California are to illegal alien Mexicans on Medi-Cal, whose births were paid for by taxpayers.
24.9% of all inmates in California detention centers are Mexican nationals here illegally.
40.1% of all inmates in Arizona detention centers are Mexican nationals here illegally.
48.2% of all inmates in New Mexico detention centers are Mexican nationals here illegally.
29% (630,000) of the inmates in all state and federal prisons are illegal aliens—at a cost of $1.6 billion annually.
More than 53% of all investigated burglaries reported in California, New Mexico, Nevada, Arizona, and Texas are perpetrated by illegal aliens.
More than half of all gang members in Los Angeles are illegal aliens from south of the border.
More than 43% of all Food Stamps issued are to illegal aliens.
More than 41% of all unemployment checks issued in the United States are to illegal aliens.
58% of all welfare payments in the United States are issued to illegal aliens.
Nearly 60% of all occupants of HUD properties in the United States are illegal aliens.
14 out of 31 TV stations in L.A. are Spanish-only.
16 out of 28 TV stations in Phoenix are Spanish only.
15 out of 24 TV stations in Albuquerque are Spanish-only.
More than 34% of Arizona students in grades 1-12 are illegal aliens.
More than 24% of Arizona students in grades 1-12 are non-English speaking.
More than 39% of California students in grades 1-12 are illegal aliens.
More than 42% of California students in grades 1-12 are non-English speaking.
In Los Angeles County, 5.1 million people speak English and 3.9 million speak Spanish.
More than 71% of all apprehended cars stolen in 2005 in Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, Nevada, and California were stolen by illegal aliens or transport “coyotes.”
47% of cited/stopped drivers in California have no license, no insurance, and no registration for the vehicle. Of that 47%, 92% are illegal aliens.
63% of cited/stopped drivers in Arizona have no license, no insurance, and no registration for the vehicle. Of that 63%, 97% are illegal aliens.
66% of cited/stopped drivers in New Mexico have no license, no insurance, and no registration for the vehicle. Of that 66%, 98% are illegal aliens.
Less than 2% of illegal aliens in the United States are picking crops, but 41% are on welfare.
Over 70% of the United States annual population growth (and over 90% of California, Florida, and New York) results from illegal immigration, at a cost of nearly $68,000,000,000.00 annually.”
64 Responses to “Illegal Immigration Statistics”
leave your opinion on this subject
Or check out related stickers and shirts in the store.














Amazing numbers and sad this never makes it to congress to be discussed. All sellouts.
Too bad all this information is fake.
The United States Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) was a part of the United States Department of Justice and handled legal and illegal immigration and naturalization.
It ceased to exist as a whole entity on March 1, 2003 thus no 2006 “INS/FBI” documents…
There is no link to any “From the 2006 (lst Qtr) INS/FBI Statistical Report” on the site linked above, just more links to alarmist right-wing political blogs.
Come up with an actual “2006 (lst Qtr) INS/FBI Statistical Report” and then you might have something.
Your right darren, immigration isnt a problem, there are no illegals here in the US.
How bout you go down to walmart and look down any aisle at all and you tell me if these numbers are acurate.
Keep in mind we are a thousand miles from the nearest border in Charlotte, and still it looks like a la raza march in Walmart.
Lets just use this one local numbet then
“The growth is also due to the high birth rate of Hispanics and illegal immigrants in Mecklenburg County. Between 2001 and 2005, Hispanic students accounted for 57% of the total growth in North Carolina Public Schools. However, the full impact of illegal or legal immigration for the school system cannot be determined, as Charlotte Mecklenburg Schools, like schools across the country, do not ask for citizenship status when students are enrolled for the academic year, based largely on a U.S. Supreme Court ruling. ”
57% of new students are taking resources and forcing my kids into portable classroooms.
That 57% look about on mark with the other numbers.
Or just look out the window at every landscaper in our city. Keep in mind there are NO WORK VISA for cutting lawns, and you need command of the english language for citizenship….so all those criminals you see are part of that statistic.
Right wing what? try common sense, look out your window.
http://www.charmeck.org/Departments/Mayor/ImmigrationStudy/Education.htm
A 2006 study by Edwin S. Rubenstein, a former contributing editor for Forbes, commissioned by the National Policy Institute last year stated that, “Illegal aliens cost the American taxpayer $25 billion more than they pay in taxes.” Titled “The Economics of Immigration Enforcement”, the study concluded that they cost U.S. citizens an estimated $81 billion per year. “Amnesty would make things worse,” stated the study, “by adding another $44 billion to government spending for services.”
Just go search illegal aliens research and see the gross abuse of laws and 3rd world traits pouring over the border.
–Law enforcement officials estimate that 20% of gang members in San Diego County are illegal, according to the Union-Tribune.
– The L.A. County Sheriff reported in 2000 that 23% of inmates in county jails were deportable, according to the New York Times.
– In Los Angeles, 95 percent of all outstanding warrants for homicide in the first half of 2004 (which totaled 1,200 to 1,500) targeted illegal aliens. Up to two-thirds of all fugitive felony warrants (17,000) were for illegal aliens.
–The Los Angeles Police Department arrests about 2500 criminally-convicted deportees annually, reports the Los Angeles Times.
you can research the sources yourself darren, but your denial of the obvious is pretty sad.
http://www.manhattan-institute.org
/html/mac_donald04-13-05.htm
And if you have kids who drive Darren….here you go.
“Statewide, more than one-third of California drivers are without insurance, according to the California Department of Insurance. In some low-income and minority neighborhoods, the rate is over 50 percent. In San Jose, for instance, 55 percent of all drivers on the road have no auto insurance. In some parts of Los Angeles, Imperial, San Diego and Alameda counties, the rate reaches as high as 90 percent.
The situation isn’t much better in other states with high populations of illegals. In Texas, 27 percent of drivers are uninsured. In Florida, the estimates are between 15 and 25 percent. In Colorado, 32 percent.
There are no official statistics about highway carnage and illegal aliens. But there is an increasing awareness among law enforcement officials – and victims of traffic accidents – that illegal aliens are playing a disproportionate role in the road mayhem.
According to surveys conducted by Mothers Against Drunk Driving, Hispanics believe it takes 6-8 drinks to affect driving, while Americans, indoctrinated for years against drunk driving, believe it takes just 2-4 drinks.
In 2001, MADD reported 44.1 percent of California’s drunk driving arrests were of Hispanics, while, officially, they made up just 31.3 percent of the population.”
Thos look like what Is published above.
Well darren the fbi existed in 2005, and they compiled research data as a part of their daily workload, as shown here.
http://www.fbi.gov/ucr/05cius/
So you concluding its “fake” based on a name change of the department, is the same kind of “make believe” liberal crap that allows free for all border dashes and hospital closures in liberal states.
You call the websites showing this information as “alarmist right wing”, but since the goal here is
1. make the laws.
2. enforce the laws you make.
3. punish those that break the laws accordingly.
That sounds like pretty basic government role crap to me.
Common sense is too hard to fathom for bleeding heart liberals.
It’s amazing how people believe what they want despite the evidence. THERE WAS NO 2006 FBI/INS REPORT!!!!!!! IT’S NOT TRUE!! THE FACT THAT YOU KNOW IT’S NOT TRUE AND CONTINUE TO REPEAT IT MAKES IT A LIE!!!!!
Many of these have been debunked multiple times:
http://www.snopes.com/politics/immigration/taxes.asp
You are right, but many of them also validated in that same post, or near enough to validated to be alarming.
`FROM YOUR LINK’
The FBI reports half of all gang members in Los Angeles are most likely illegal aliens from south of the border.
And the facts it shows are:
A confidential California Department of Justice study reported in 1995 that 60 percent of the 20,000-strong 18th Street Gang in southern California is illegal; police officers say the proportion is actually much greater. The bloody gang collaborates with the Mexican Mafia, the dominant force in California prisons, on complex drug-distribution schemes, extortion, and drive-by assassinations. It commits an assault or robbery every day in L.A. County. The gang has grown dramatically over the last two decades by recruiting recently arrived youngsters, most of them illegal, from Central America and Mexico.
Keep in mind the problem is FAR WORSE now than in 1995, the lat 12 years has doubled the issue.
So you link shows this “LIE” is likely very true or close to it.
Shall we bicker over 40% of gang members are illegals or 60%?
Is either number not a case to enforce the border?
“…60 percent of the 20,000-strong 18th Street Gang ….police officers say the proportion is actually much greater. The bloody gang collaborates with the Mexican Mafia, the dominant force in California prisons”
That is NOT A MYTH, thats from your urban legend link as fact.
Whether these numbers are correct or incorrect isn’t at issue here. The fact remains that we have a growing number of illegal immigrants living in the USA. No foreign person has a right to enter this country, it’s a privilege.
There is a legal way to enter this country. When these people purposely violate our laws, they become criminals. They do not deserve the rights they are protesting for. Yet with all the benefits they can receive such as welfare, the ability to hold a job, the free education for their illegal children, medical care that tax payers pay for, I just cant see what rights they dont already have.I don’t base those benefits on what I have been told, but what I have seen personally.
It is also estimated that 1-3 million illegal immigrants invade this country yearly. Granting amnesty is not the answer because in as little as four years we will have this problem all over again.
I don’t blame them, “the illegals”, and we are way beyond deportation. Yet the answer is simple, go after the people and businesses that employ them. Take their jobs away and make them want to go back home.
I am not sure if I should believe the statistics on this website, but I just want to comment on this.
Don’t forget that U.S. Citizens aren’t the only ones being affected by illegal immigrants. Legal immigrants are affected in the same way also because they work hard and pay taxes just like ant U.S. citizen.
It may be true that illegal immigrants take jobs that no American wants, but everybody is either forgetting something or unaware of it.
A lot of legal immigrants also do the dirty jobs that no American wants also because many of them lack English and they need these jobs because they have no choice.
If in fact that illegal immigrants don’t take jobs away from U.S citizens, then they are taking these opportunities away from legal immigrants who worked hard for their paperwork to come here to this country for a better life and can contribute to society better than illegal immigrants and it is unfair to the legal immigrants. Legal immigrants contribute more to society than illegal immigrants because not only do they work, but they also pay taxes. Illegal immigrants only just take and take and never give back to society.
I don’t know how illegal immigrants can receive unemployment checks, welfare, food stamps, medicaid, and government payments for delivering their babies. They are illegal immigrants and should not be entitled to them.
These benefits are coming out of tax dollars that paid by hard working U.S. Citizens and hard working Legal immigrants and yet illegal immigrants never return favors to them.
When low-income U.S. Citizens and low-income legal immigrants need these govermental benefits, they need to work hard and pay taxes to the government to convert them into the benefits they need and illegal immigrants just drains it out of governmnent funding. Since U.S. Citizens and legal immigrants are paying the taxes, they and their family members should be the only ones getting these benefits.
When landlords rent out apartments to illegal immigrants(Which they are not supposed to do), many illegal immigrants who rent the apartments would divide up the rooms and take the role as a landlord to rent these rooms to other families and they become not only very extremely overcrowded, but it can also be dangerous to the environment and other residents.
When there are multiple families in one apartment, the apartment becomes very messy because of the extreme overcrowdedness and a fire or any dangers to the environment can occur. If there is a dangerous event such as a fire, it will be difficult for people to evacuate and endanger a lot of lives.
When illegal immigrants rent apartments and allow multiple families to live in one apartments, they often rent them in tenement buildings which can be more dangerous to the environment because the tenements are already overcrowded even if it is only one family in an apartment and the tenements are often in bad conditions.
Before a wave of illegal immigrants started taking over tenements and communities, it was bad enough for one legal immigrant family that produced low-income to live in an apartment in the tenements because the apartments are small and very little bedrooms and often very small. The parents would take the bedrooms which are often to small and push their children into the living room to sleep. It is unpleasant to the environment, but I also understand it completely. Sometimes the legal immigrant families would have so little income that they couldn’t afford a house or a better apartment and they are stuck where they are.
I understand it because my family members are immigrants(legally) and I happen to live in that situation.
But when you allow multiple illegal immigrant families to live in one apartment especially in the tenements, that is way too overcrowded, a lot more dangerous to the environment and that is different.
Just some things I forgot to mention. I also blame the government and immigration services for this problem.
The government is too lenient and doesn’t have enough strict enforcements. The rules of the immigration services are not as flexible and that is why we have too many illegal immigrants.
The rules of immigration are, you must have a legal family member in America to make the paperwork for you to immigrate here or you must have a temporary Visa(ex. student visa, work visa)to allow yourself to eventually work for a permanent Visa.
Those rules should still stay in the immigration rules, but create new ones to allow foriegners who have no family members in this country to be able to get onto the waiting list for visas, but to a certain limit, so that way it will reduce illegal immigration.
Here are other steps I think the government should do to stop illegal immigration. The government should make it a requirement to renew your social security every five to eight years with a new photo attached and have a federal bar code to electronically verify identity. This can stop illegal immigrants from using someone’s identity, reduce identity theft, and catch people who are producing fake documents. If the government ever does do something like this, it should never be announced to the public because it will give people new productive ideas on how to steal someone’s identity.
The government should assign governmental advisors to every business owner, landlords, and real estate agencies to stop the employing illegal immigrants and stop renting apartments to illegal immigrants.
It should be a requirement for an employer to go to the governmental advisor for approval for hiring a new employee and doing thorough identity verification on the future employee. Once the governmental advisor has approved of the person being employed, the employee should be required to get an ID from thwe governmnetal advisor for access to the employment site.
The advisor should do an investgation on the employment site every 6 months to make sure there are no new employees without the approval of the advisor. The investigation should be searched of every inch of the area to make sure no one is hiding. The employer should face fines for hiring a new unapproved illegal worker and have the illegal worker fired.
The landlords and Real estate agencies should also follow the same rules for allowing new residents to move in. Once the residents have been thoroughly verified and approved, they should have their photos taken and attached to their records to make sure they are authorized resudents. There should also be an investigation every 6 months to make sure there are no unapproved residents. If landlords are found to have housed illegal residents, they should be facing big fines and the illegal residents should be evicted.
We talk,talk,and talk. Enough! How about we throw CEO’s in jail for hiring Illegals? Turn off the damn job magnet and these people will have nothing to stay here for. No work, no stay. Ask your self this; who did these jobs Americans wont do before this problem got so out of control? ENFORCE EXISTING LAW ALREADY ON THE BOOKS,CLOSE THE DAMN BORDER, AND FINALLY AND MOST IMPORTANT ELECT LEADERSHIP THAT UNDERSTANDS WHAT A THREAT THIS INVASION IS TO THE FUTURE OF AMERICA.
I hear a lot of people blaming the Government for not being strict in enforcing the laws.
I am sure many of you are aware of this, but for those who are not I will briefly explain.
The Government’s problem is not that it is not strict enough. The problem is that the Gov’t is purposely allowing it for many reasons. The main reason is its hopes of establishing the “North American Union” which is the greatest threat to our country today. I truly wish everyone understood what dire trouble our country is in at this very moment.
If you wish to learn more about the NAU this website is very insightful. http://www.stopthenorthamericanunion.com/
Why are you still reading this? Click on the damn link. Learn of the treason and tell every damn person you know. We don’t have much time.
You guys are all senseless. I hope you’re all reincarnated as a poor person who has a poor family in Mexico and forced to come to America illegally.
And that you come back as a border agent jailed for 11 years for shooting a drug runner.
“forced”…now thats senseless.
I can understand if people are living in terrible situations, but if I were inn that situation, I would try to find some ways to survive, but I wouldn’t do anything that was wrong and unlawful.
I wonder what your immigrant ancestors would have said if they heard you talking that way? They would have called you a nativist and spanked you. Twice as many immigrants came around the turn of the century then are entering now. All illegal…all hated by the same nativist sentiments supported here. If you like the prices the things you buy, and your way of life, you better start thinking of ways to fix this thing instead of who is to blame.
My ancestors? My legal immigrant parents, legal immigrant wife and hispanic family dont need your grade school guilt trip.
The prices of things I bought in 1985 were pretty good, so was the quality of life….and we had 75% less criminal aliens and didnt have a fiesta in front of every home depot.
The US allows more LEGAL immigrants than any country on the planet, so your guilt trip doesnt seem to realize this fact.
We have the most generous immigration system on the planet in terms of volume and percentage of population.
If you wish to show me what other country LEGALLY takes in more immigrants, more hispanic immigrants OR more Mexican immigrants…Im listening.
Our quality of life is better because real Americans respect laws and put america first.
Oh please. REAL Americans respect laws and put America first? What about the current Pre$ident, VICE PreSident and the other cronies, who have slipped away to save Bush’s butt? Respecting laws! I laugh at your naievity! Our current elected government is cashing in, thumbing their noses at us and laughing all the way to retirement and the ruin that perhaps even their OWN party may be forced to try to rebuild!
Linda, do you really think the term “real Americans” refer to the handful of people in the White House?
You dont ever equate that to mean the other 300,000 million people in the country?
You are quite well trained to repeat the same robot response of BUSH DID IT.
But guess what, were not talking about parties here, were talking about America.
Too bad leftists like yourself put the party before the country as a single unit.
The party thanks you comrade!
But try to stay on topic or save it for the dailykos
It is quite depressing that people like you try to create an evil image of all illegal immigrants that come to America. You ignorant ######! go to a third world country and live the torture and poverty they are forced to deal with every day. Yes, some illegal immigrants are Mexican and commit crimes, don’t whites, blacks, and legal hispanics commit crimes as well?Your article is biast and apart from that, your stats are completely off. Why don’t you go and get some valid information before you write another ####### article that infects Americans with a false image of most illegal immigrants.
Joanne, Ignorance would be lack of knowledge on a subject. I would contend that I have more first hand knowledge of immigration and illegal immigrants than you will have in 10 lifetimes.
My family is hispanic, my kids as well. My wife cam here legally from a spanish speaking latin nation. We worked hard for 5 years to do it legally.
for 2 years she could not work because it WOULD HAVE BEEN ILLEGAL. We could have used the second income, but it would have been illegal and against immigration rules.
I also helped her parents, sister, brother and first cousins all come here leaglly as well by sponsering them.
90% of our friends are latino, many of them illegal.
My family has had their ID stolen 2 times in the frist 4 years living here.
Because they have hispanic names the ungrateful illegals steal their ID.
I has to work to remove the hits from my father in law’s credit from that one.
The latest was someone stealing DIRECT TV on my wife’s mothers credit. And yes they had the “extended language pack”.
So guess what, illegal immigrants are criminals. They broke the law knowingly and that shows no respect for Americans.
So forgive me if I dont cry for your little fantasyland where there are no borders and we all live in a third world surrounding in harmony.
My friends are legal and illegal. They know how I feel. I dont judge them as people based on that, but I do judge MY OWN government on its refusal to enforce our laws.
So Joanne, go out and get a real education on the subject and then I will waste more space enlightening you.
And please try not to use the TYPICAL liberal name calling and pretend it is an “argument”.
Try making a point in the future.
I might be slightly biased being the son of legal immigrant parents but there is large flaws in these statistics. This newspaper is full of conservative theories also known as racist theories. Its discouraging to find that racism is still so prevalent in the United States. It was all right for your immigrant ancestors to come to America which is the beacon of freedom yet you are so willing to deny illegals the basic liberties they are stipped of, in their own country. Also, illegal immigrants are going into the US to earn a better living, and its a shame that you would slander illegal immigration with statistics of the minority of illegal immigrants who are convicts. Its the 21st century, please realize that people are all the same regardless of ethnicity.
Yet again, the only defense for 20 million people in violation of our laws is to call people who respect the law “racists”
Provide me with another argument with some facts. Also show me what other country accepts more legal immigrants than the US? (none).
Show me what other country endures so many illegal immigrants as the US does? (none)
Show me what Central American country treats Illegal immigration as a misdemeanor?
(none) - felony in mexico.
Conservative want laws enforced, and you call that racist. I remond you that hispanic and black senators helped to write those laws in 1986.
Defend that, are they racist too.
Liberals just want to import lower class voters, because the earn voters with handouts, something conservatives and Republicans do not want.
You want handouts for minority groups and to ignore the law based on race, that is the only form of racism here, expecting americans to ignore laws because of your minority group.
Also, LEGAL Hispanic Americans dont always want criminal aliens here either.
In Arizona 49% of hispanics voted against PROP 300 to allow instate tuition and grants for illegals.
So even honest true Americans of hispanic families understand that the law needs to be enforced against these criminals.
Thanks for stopping by with no facts and calling everyone a racist though……best just to let you speak and give yourself away as uninformed.
Ok, I understand that people want a better life for their family and they want the “American Dream”, but the fact is that they are doing more damage to this country and take away the “American Dream”.
What I think needs to happen is we make becoming a legal immigrant easier in the US and we offer limited time peroid jobs where we ship people from Mexico to America for work and after a certain time period we send them back. If it is government controled taxes would be payed and the people who need the money get the money and live in Mexico. I know the arguement on the other side might be “By doing that you would take away Jobs for Ameicans”, my response to that is We have been so blessed by God in this Country their really isn’t a good excuse for someone that is healthy to not be educated and working.
Wrong numbers or not too many illegal immigrants are in America for us to remain the greatest Country and if you don’t like it move to Europe where their are no boarders
Dave
WOW. Whoever wrote this really needs to do some research. These statistics are very wrong. There’s only about 6 channels that are in spanish in Phoenix and there’s a lot of channels. If you don’t like it then don’t watch it. You people really need to grow up and educate yourselves. You need to make a hobby to occupy yourselves instead of placing your noses were it doesn’t belong
What a wonderful way of have the new kind of racism:
” JUSTIFIED RACISM”
Most of you are just ignorant people, who just see America as the whole world but yeah let’s kick every single illegal allien out, and then let’s see what America becomes, yes a third world country.
Illegal Alliens out = companies will outsource= no jobs for Americans= no money to spend= CRISIS.
But let’s do it, I am excited to see the results.
I want to see you bring back every single one of those illegal immigrants like what one of the cities in CA did a couple weeks ago.
Funny Andrew, My nose belongs here into he US, but you defend those who put their noses, feet, kids crime and needs where it doesnt belong?
In the US?
Andrew, Better yet, lets just open the border in SO-Cal….legal immigration for everyone.
Then lets build a fence around California.
Tey will be jumping that fence in 10 years when California was ruined with 3rd world lifestyles and standard of living.
All points would be made about why we protect our interests with legal immigration…the most generous immigration system ON THE PLANET, as it is today.
For the most part, I have to agree with you, Michael. Have we all forgotten what the word ILLEGAL means?
The definition of illegal is, “prohibited by law or by official or accepted rules.”
Now, we all refer to those persons who enter our country in other ways than the lawfully accepted procedure as “illegal immigrants”. This is immediately saying that they are breaking the law. They have entered this country in and unlawful manner, therefore making them criminals.
What more needs to be said? We provide health care and jobs to criminals running around on the street. Why must we put up with this? Yet we are called racist for trying to put up a fight against it. Seriously people, what ARE we coming to.
I don’t care if the illegal immigrant came from Latin America, Europe, Africa, the Middle east, or anywhere else. He/she should be evicted from our country immediately.
The fact is that (as has been said in past posts) the statistics at the top are not the issue anymore. I don’t care if they are wrong. I care because no matter how exagerated these statistics are we STILL do have a problem. We are being invaded.
Why should we give benefits such as health care and driver licenses to people who have become criminals? No matter how bad a situation is in a third world country, those who truly wish to immigrate can do it legally. Yes, it takes work. Gaining the freedoms that we take for granted today took work for our Country to grant. We fought a whole war for those freedoms people. So why can’t people legally immigrate? It’s not any easier in ANY other country in the world.
I also hasten to add that the “third world countries” are quickly becoming second world countries.
The whole shebang about first, second, and third world countries came about as a result of the Soviet Union.
First World means: The United States, Great Britain, and their allies in the fight against communism.
Second World means: Communist countries
Third World means: those countries that are too small (or neutral) to make a difference.
Many of these Latin American countries are turning to communism. They are becoming SECOND WORLD countries.
Come on people, lets get serious. Why should we give all of our freedoms to those who are breaking our laws? The fact that they have Broken the law means that they give up their freedoms to act as they choose. Why else do we put people in jail? Because they broke the law, these people have shown that they can’t handle these freedoms. So lets not give them to illegal immigrants.
I am nineteen and I am a freshmen,girl in college. I was assigned to write about illegal immigration and the negative effects it has on our economy and stumbled across this.
It is absolutly disgusting how much money is wasted on people who unlawfully come to America. From someone just coming out of the educational system of our country, illegal students do nothing but lessen the learning enviroment. Everyday in the lunch line these illegal aliens would get to the cafeteria first, i don’t know how, but by the time the paying students, such as myself, would get to the line it would be half way out of the cafeteria. We had a blind student at our school, very briefly, my school could not fund brail classes for her so she had to leave. Which was very ironic because the school could fund ESOL classes, every period of the day, which were overcrowded so they had to hire a teachers assistance….more money. I think I counted at least three buses with Mexican students on them…unnessicary expenditure for the citizens. You want to talk about gangs? A kid died in my class from a gang shooting. Illegal Mexican “gangster” girls used to pull razors out from under their tounges in the bathroom. I had two classes with pregnaunt illegal citizens…Mexican! You know whats really funny about all this crime and low funds? I live in a upper class suburb called Dunwoody in Atlanta Georgia. Puff Daddy and the Wendy’s owner lives near me. We don’t even have many cops around here. But sure enough at school we had two cops and a drug dog. I’m tired of pulling up to gas staitons and seeing the illegal workers stand around and wait for jobs. I’m tired of volunteering at homeless shelters and not being able to understand what the people are saying. I’m tired of giving money away to people who don’t return it and think it’s owed. I DO NOT CARE THAT YOUR COUNTRY SUCKS! MAYBE INSTEAD OF MAKING MINE SUCK AND USING SO MUCH EFFORT TO COME HERE, YOU CAN DIRECT YOUR EFFORT INTO TAKING A STAND AGAINST YOUR OWN COUNTRIES GOVERMENT, AND STOP STEALING FROM AND HARRASSING MY GOVERMENT!!
Hi. I’m a twenty year old college student, and suggest that if you want to make truly informed decisions and formulate good opinions based on facts that you take a sociology class. As a whole, illegal and legal foreign-born immigrants make up 11.5% of our country’s population, or about 31 million people, according to the Center for Immigration Studies. The largest percentage of any specific “illegal immigrant” group is actually from people who mostly appear to be caucasian, but are from countries closest to Europe, not Mexico. Those countries include, but are not limited to, England, France, Poland, Russia, Yugoslavia, what used to be known as Czechoslovakia, and various other countries on the same continent. How do these people get here? They come here with a visa, and when their visa expires, they simply stay. Generally, people tend to notice “outsiders” with a different skin color -and- who speak a different language before they think that someone who looks similarly would be from a different country.
It’s important to uphold our countries’ laws, but don’t use our laws as a way to justify racism and traditionalism. If you want to protect the sanctity and freedom American citizens enjoy, get educated, get your facts straight, and argue cleanly. Most of the argument techniques being used on this page fall into a few categories of fallacies, i.e. things that are untrue assumptions: circular logic (example: “I believe what I’ve been taught because I go to school.”), the slippery slope fallacy (example: “If we allow this to happen, this next thing will also follow suit.”), and oversimplification, also known as the Either/or fallacy (example: “Either you’re with us or against us.”).Take a philosophy course, read up on the stuff you’re saying before you say it. Also, because I’m giving facts that tend to favor illegal immigrants, don’t assume I’d open the gates of the U.S. to anyone who wants to come here. One last fun thing to leave you with; I’m not exactly a follower of Christianity, but do you remember the Golden Rule? “Treat others as you would want to be treated?” How do you want to be treated in this world? Do you want to be treated the same way as what most of those against immigration deem as appropriate for those who come here illegally? When you realize that everyone’s race is simply “human,” that you should treat people as humans and not as numbers, and that “ethnicity” pertains to how you’re raised, your culture, your language, and a whole lot of other factors, I think you may be heading towards being educated enough to speak openly about your opinions. Goodnight everyone, and thank you for reading.
One last thing… Third World countries don’t provide free college for their students… but Mexico does.
Julie, You need to stop making the insulting move of lumpiing legal foreigners with criminal aliens
“As a whole, illegal and legal foreign-born immigrants make up 11.5% of our country’s population, or about 31 million people”
I know alot of people (my family included) that went through the process of being a legal American, and they dont appreciate you or your liberal professors lumping them together.
Did you professor explain hom ILLEGAL immigrants hurt legal hispanic immgrants more than anyone else?
Who do you think is depressing the wages of who? I have 3-4 legal hispanic immigrant relatives that will teach you about how they get paid far less because of ILLEGAL labor.
What about their rights not to have lawbreakers steal their wages?
SECONDLY, Julia.
You said this “The largest percentage of any specific “illegal immigrant” group is actually from people who mostly appear to be caucasian, but are from countries closest to Europe, not Mexico. Those countries include, but are not limited to, England, France, Poland, Russia, Yugoslavia, what used to be known as Czechoslovakia,”
You try to pull race cards not me.
Nowhere does anyone say not to enforce the laws for all immigrants.
There is nothing racist about laws, and they should be enforced.
You try to suggest nobody want the law enforced on white skinned immgrants, but you made that idea up in your mind, nobody suggested it.
And also 58% of illegals are from south of teaxs, so not only is you attempted point racist but its also wrong.
THIRDLY: You say:
“One last thing… Third World countries don’t provide free college for their students… but Mexico does.”"
Then I guess we dont need the DREAM ACT, because 6-10 millions illegals have a great opportunity as soon as they return home to claim it.
Thanks for making a point for my side of the argument.
You used all the common prepackeged liberal arguments and none of them excuse the law or common sense.
who ever wrote this is a straght up hater America needs us because most whites are too lazy to do labor
I wonder who gave the legal permission to the colonists that muredered and raped the NATIVE inhabitants of the American continent to invade this territory and claim it “theirs”.
Whether you are a dem or rep, black or white, worker or student (I’m an MBA grad student myself Julie I’m embarrased for you) if you are American illegal immigration is killing your country. Financial data, social data, criminal data are all different views on the same problem - quality of life being erroded by Mexican citizens overrunning our system. Julie’s not old enough to realize who and how we are going to pay for this problem in our future. Julie - you may not be able to retire because your taxes are going to be so high, SS will be spread to thin for you to live off of (by 2040 or so and not totally from illegal immigration for that matter - this ship has other holes in it to if you know what I mean), you may not be able to afford proper healthcare (system already is almost bankrupt), etc, BUT YOU ARE WORRIED ABOUT BEING RACIST???? PROTECTING MY HARD WORKING FAMILY’S FUTURE IS NOT RACIST!!! 1/5 to 1/4 of Mexico lives in the USA. Get to 1/2 or more and we become a second world nation ourselves. Wake up.
2) Saddest part of it all is this. Our government, particularly the Bush administration, won’t do too much about it because of the currupt, symbiotic relationship we have with Mexico. How? Your answer is in the lap of big business and cheap labor. The money you and I work for is part of the same financial structure, ie same money, that won’t completely close the border.
3) Good news is this. By 2045 or so we’ll be old, China will be the most powerful nation on earth, last of the rain forests will be made into Chinese and Indian houses, walruses, penguins and polar bears will be almost extinct, resourses will be fought fiercly for and guess what? Illigal immigration will once again be more towards the back burner….
I am a teenager who, instead of getting drunk and slacking off like most of my peers, takes the initiative to form solid opinions concerning culture and politics, and I have to say:
I am so thrilled to see people voicing some real common sense, and speaking up for the good of America and its LEGAL inhabitants. As one can see from these comments, liberal “ideals” and cliches can not stand up to cold, hard facts.
i came to this coutry 25 years ago legaly. it cost me alot of money lots of paper work and waiting. i left mexico because the crime rate is bad gangs rapes murder kidnapping robery the police are evan worse and the pay is bad i came here for a better life and i found one leagly!i pay my taxes and bills including the 90k in S.S. now i think ill move back to mexico now that all the criminals left mexico and are taking over the U.S. istead of flying i think i’ll walk accross just to make my point
jonny wrote: I wonder who gave the legal permission to the colonists that muredered and raped the NATIVE inhabitants of the American continent to invade this territory and claim it “theirs
alright lets do a man hunt for these people and bring them to justice oh wait there all dead! not a single person in this country is responsable for that make a real argument.
too bad all this info is FAKE!!
These statistics are BS
Go to wal-mart && look who is paying with well-fare & credit cards….yea that’s right, the white man, not the mexicans.
&& its not the mexicans fault that it takes so damn long for them to get citizenship!!
“its not the mexicans fault that it takes so damn long for them to get citizenship”
You sir are retarded. Its also no Americans obligation to give citizenship to anyone who tries to steal it.
Money taken from the US economy and “mailed” home to mexico is the second largest source of money in the Mexican economy.
That is a fact.
And since when are Americans the “white man”?
Americans are all races, and only 49% of the nation is white now. The rest are legal americans of all colors, and all agree that supporting the welfare stae of two countries is not our responsibility.
Mabe you should complain about why you are leaving your nation and not why you are not welcome to SNEAK into mine.
Ask Felipe why there is no work in Mexico dont complain because the US doesnt want to sole Mexicos problems for them.
Also keep in mind that In Mexican law sneaking in is a felony and jailable. Repeat ofenders can get 10 ears in jail for illegal immigration in Mexico.
So again you are all hypocrites looking for the US to solve the problems of the failed economy in Mexico.
Have a great day.
If the U.S. has such a big problem with the mexican coming over to the U.S. maybe they should try to do something about it so that it stops!
Maybe like helping the mexican government, it wouldn’t take that much work && everyone benefits out of it
That way the Americans can stop bitching about mexicans supposedly taking the jobs when the truth is, americans are either to lazy to do the jobs or can’t even pass a simple drug test to get the job.
Those are some interesting statistics I did not get a chance to read the whole article. But I was wondering were you got them because I am working on an immigration topic.
Thanks
Michael Kraft I respect your argument and understand illegal immigration is a problem, but you are skewing people’s opinions with inaccurate facts. On top of that, your counter arguments for some of these people’s comments are again composed of inaccurate facts. Where do you get these numbers from? I would like links or books to verify you data because giving false information sways the views of the general public, especially those whom don’t know the facts.
CBS News “In U.S. Illegally, But Still Paying Taxes. Search that
Business Week Econ 101 on Illegal Immigrants. Search that
There are estimated 11 million undocumented immigrants (illegal immigrants) in this country which I believe Julie finally got right. Recent statistics from the Pew Hispanic Research Center indicate that undocumented immigrants account for about 4.9% of the civilian labor force, or 7.2 million workers out of a total U.S labor force of 148 million. I think we can all agree that’s a small percentage. In 2004 alone the IRS received 7.9 million W-2s with names that didn’t match a Social Security Number, which leads experts to believe they likely represent the wages of illegal immigrants. Now this is the number I want you to wrap your fingers around, and tell me how to make sense of it. Each year, the U.S. Social Security Administration maintains roughly $6-7 BILLION of Social Security contributions in an “earnings suspense file”, which means, and account for a W-2 tax form that cannot be matched to the correct Social Security number. Most if not all of this money are attributable to ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS WHO WILL NEVER CLAIM THEIR BENEFITS. The question is where is this money is going??? Because not even the article tells us. This idea that most if not all illegal immigrants have “under the table paying jobs” is a misconception, just as many if not more have tax paying jobs. Money they will never get back or deserve back. To me there are more Americans with “under the table jobs” than illegal immigrants. Why, because there are incredibly more U.S. Citizens in this country than illegal immigrants who take “under the table jobs” to avoid paying TAXES.
“Americans are all races, and only 49% of the nation is white now. The rest are legal americans of all colors,”
Incorrect my friend again. This country has always been predominately white and will remain predominately white as long as whites keep reproducing. Whites are approximately 64% of the population, and that’s not counting the illegal immigrant ones from Europe.
well my very informed friend rossini, i live in houston texas, and i am very pleased to inform you that whites are now a minority where i live.
so therefor my children should recive free college like all other minorities in the united states, just like all of the other “illegal aliens” that dont exist.
our government spends billions of dollars a year on people that dont even pay their taxes
i pay my taxes and believe that it is time that MY COUNTRY starts to recongize that and give back to the TRUE CITIZENS of America!
if ANYONE opposes me then i would love to hear you invaild arguement
Rossini, i beleive that you are a filthy communist and need to get your facts straight, and realize that the ILLEGAL ALIENS are screwing over the American citizens, and that includes you and your faimily and future generations of America to come!
if this trend continues, eventually the national language of the ONCE GLORIOUS UNITED STATES OF AMERICA will be Spanish!
why dont you mull that over for a while!
I PROPOSE THE FOLLOWING IMMIGRATION LAWS :
1. There will be no special bilingual programs in the schools.
2. All ballots will be in this nation’s language.
3. All government business will be conducted in our language.
4. Non-residents will NOT have the right to vote no matter how long they are here.
5. Non-citizens will NEVER be able to hold political office.
6. Foreigners will not be a burden to the taxpayers. No welfare, no food stamps, no health care, or other government assistance programs. Any burden will be deported.
7. Foreigners can invest in this country, but it must be an amount at least equal to 40,000 times the daily minimum wage.
8. If foreigners come here and buy land… options will be restricted. Certain parcels including waterfront property are reserved for citizens naturally born into this country.
9. Foreigners may have no protests; no demonstrations, no waving of a foreign flag, no political organizing, no bad- mouthing our president or his policies. These will lead to deportation.
10. If you do come to this country illegally, you will be actively hunted &, when caught, sent to jail until your deportation can be arranged. All assets will be taken from you.
Too Harsh?
The above laws are current immigration laws of MEXICO
Im sorry but Mike’s comment on how:
“Your right darren, immigration isnt a problem, there are no illegals here in the US.”
Really cracks me up. that’s a load of BS. Illegals are everywhere, apparently you are blind
I would expect that is easy to recognize as sarcasm. Just goto Walmart in Charlotte on Harris and you can see about 25% illegal aliens in the aisles.
Honestly… but who here goes up to people in wal mart and asks if they are illegal immigrants?
Seems to me that its always the border jumpers or the buisness owners that are infavor of illegals. The rest of us dont benefeit and i think you all should be thrown in prison and charged with a fellony for hiring them.Its killing our economy. Soon enough well all be broke,that means you to, and then what will you say.Youll have sold your country out for a few extra $$.To me thats treason.It should be a felony charge to hire illegal aliens punishable with a mandatory year in prison and 10k$ fine per illegal hired.I wrote my gov.and he said i need to write my senator.Of course they arent going to listen to just 1 person,but i see now just how they pass the buck.If anythings going to get done itll have to get done so that they make money on it,other wise it falls on deaf ears.
these stats are just rediculous. they are part of the reason our country has such a high national debt. we are forced to focus to large a portion of our government funding to try and keep those bastards south of the border. if they want to save time and money, instead of building a border wall they should try using land mines and send someone out to check them each month. that my friends is the american way to solve a problem
Quote
I can understand if people are living in terrible situations, but if I were inn that situation, I would try to find some ways to survive, but I wouldn’t do anything that was wrong and unlawful.
so you’d rather live in a bad situation and not try to improve your/your families standard of living than break a law that you have no say in and probably don’t believe in or care about.
right….. don’t believe it.
Quote
Rossini, i beleive that you are a filthy communist and need to get your facts straight, and realize that the ILLEGAL ALIENS are screwing over the American citizens, and that includes you and your faimily and future generations of America to come!
It’s not hardworking illegal aliens that are screwing over America, its stupid fucks like you that blame a cyclical economy and its current downswing and the fact that there dumb ass doesn’t have a job on illegals that are looking for a better way of life.
Also, good job attacking one of the few intelligent posts here.
Quote
if this trend continues, eventually the national language of the ONCE GLORIOUS UNITED STATES OF AMERICA will be Spanish!
I’m reading and rereading this and really don’t see that problem that you obviously see with this statement, guess I’m not as racist as you….
Side note : I dunno why you want free college for your kids, if they are anything like you they have no hope of getting into college.
19, TX, Engineering College Student
I’m a high school freshman and my mom has lung cancer. Since my dad works and my brother and I need to go to school, my mom has to stay home by herself. My aunt was given a temporary visa, which took months to get, just so she could come and take care of my mom. I know I’m not very educated about this topic, but I think it’s unfair that illegal immigrants can come more easily, even if there’s the consequences for them.
There are an estimated 11 million illegal aliens currently residing within the borders of the United States of America. Many critics believe a more accurate estimate is closer to 20 million. No matter what the number is, there are serious implications these undocumented people place on the American society!
Implication number one – there is an enormous financial burden placed upon American taxpayers to cover the cost of housing illegal aliens. According to the Federation for American Immigration Reform FAIR, “The annual net cost of illegal immigrants (after subtracting their tax payments) to the American taxpayer is likely to be more than $45 billion.” Costs include the use of the Medicare system, the use of our public education, incarceration of criminals, use of the welfare system, and the cost of the immigration system itself.
Implication number two – with illegal immigration comes illegal criminals. It does not take a genius to figure that if there are 11 million people living in this county unaccounted for, some of those people are bad. In fact The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO), in a 04/07/05 report to Congress entitled “Information on Criminal Aliens Incarcerated in Federal and State Prisons and Local Jails,” states that at the end of 2004 there were approximately 49,000 illegal aliens incarcerated out of a total of 179,000 inmates (a 27% rate of illegal inmates) at an estimated cost of 1.2 billion dollars to house them. Some of the most ruthless criminals, in fact, are illegal aliens. Members of the MS-13 gang, 18th Street gang, Columbia Lil’ Cycos gang, and numerous other gangs are filtering violent criminals through our borders and harboring them here. One murderer, rapist, sexual predator, or drug/arms trafficker is too many.
Implication number three – our children’s education suffers because of the overcrowding illegal children cause. According to Pew Hispanic Center, 3.1 million citizen children are born to an unauthorized parent, and 1.6 million children are unauthorized themselves for a total of 4.7 million children under the age of 18 that need to be educated. The time and energy a teacher uses to teach a non-English speaking student should be used solely to further the educational interests of native English speaking children.
Implication number four – illegal immigrants take jobs away from Americans. According to Pew Hispanic Center, there were approximately 7.5 million unauthorized workers in 2005. Most of the jobs these aliens hold are in low wage and low education fields. Critics will say that illegal aliens do the jobs most Americans will not do; however, low income Americans may beg to differ. Not all of the 7.5 million people are mowing lawns, picking produce, or house cleaning. Most are employed in jobs were the unscrupulous employer does not bother to check the immigration status of the worker and hires them at a rate cheaper than the minimum wage.
WE NEED TO REFORM OUR IMMIGRATION SYSTEM!
The solution to the illegal alien problem in America is quite simple. All American citizens would be required to register once a year with the DCR, Department of Citizen Registration. Automobiles, boats, bikes, etc… require yearly registration, so too will citizens. Fingerprints, photographs, social security card, and birth certificate/citizenship documentation will all be verified on a yearly basis. A Citizen Identification Number CIN will be tattooed on the person’s right wrist. A citizenship badge will be issued with the citizen’s photo, CIN number and personal information. All citizens MUST wear the badge at all times. Visitors to the country will be issued a Visitor Authorization Badge VA which must be worn at all times.
All Aliens would be subject to “Campaign X”. Any illegal alien found within the borders of the United States would be given a tattooed marking in the middle of their forehead in the shape of an X. This would be their identifying mark to let the country know they are here illegally. On their left wrist would be tattooed an Alien Identification Number AIN for tracking purposes and to make certain the identity of an American citizen has not been used. They would then be transported into specially located “Controlled Compounds” were they will be given the opportunity to work legally in the USA. They will be supplied with food, shelter and medical care; however, they must comply with any and all employment requests from the US Government, including, but not limited to physical labor, medical research, military research, etc.
A secret team of Special Service Agents (S.S.) will be authorized to conduct random searches for aliens and any persons who may be harboring such individuals. Any citizens found guilty of aiding and abedding illegal criminals will also be subject to the laws of “Campaign X”.
If an alien is employed in an approved unskilled job, he will be issued a Justly Employed Worker badge “JEW”, which must be worn at all times. He is then free to leave the “Controlled Compound”. However, if a citizen wants the job of the “JEW”, it is his citizen right to take the job at the national minimum wage rate and the employer must hire him without question. In order to satisfy an employer looking to hire cheap workers, the employer can petition the local “Controlled Compound” requesting permission to hire. If the job description is satisfactorily compatible with the hiring of aliens, then the petition will be granted. If a “JEW” is not acceptable, then the employer must call the Alien Patrol (AP) to have the “JEW” transported back to the “Controlled Compound”.
All children of aliens will not be allowed in public schools. They will instead be taught the skills necessary to be an effective “JEW”.
It is common knowledge that aliens are inferior to citizens, therefore, the purity of citizen blood must be kept clean. The sanctity of our citizen women is of the utmost importance. Any alien male caught fornicating with a citizen woman will face immediate castration.
If any of the terms of “Campaign X” are unsatisfactory to the alien, they have the right, their only right, to go back to their country of origin. The option is theirs.
Nothing like the smell of satire in the morning.
seriously if your scared that these immigrants are going to take your jobs then why don’t you go to college and better yourself, because thats exactly what a lot of these ambitious immigrants in school want to do. Unfortunately for these kids they cant afford college for the reason that financial aid will not support them, and a lot of ignorant people just scare them. so for most of you who are citizens and actually have the opportunity to do whatever you want, stop complaining seriously. Oh and these facts are not true, but i know whoever wrote this already knows that.
We work hard as a country to secure our airports and even created a no-fly list that disallows certain individuals, by name, from flying anywhere in the world. Yet our borders are more or less wide open.
1-3 million people enter this country illegally each year. Maybe more. It is a misnomer that they or even most of them are Mexican. Just as many come from Guatemala, El Salvador, etc. Iraqi nationals have been caught trying to sneak into the US from Mexico.
So how many of the 1-3 million or more that sneak into the US each year are terrorists? I would not necessarily be able differentiate between a Middle-Eastern man and a Hispanic man in that setting and in similar garb.
How many millions (maybe billions) of dollars worth of illegal drugs are smuggled into the country each year? Can’t be any more difficult to smuggle in large amounts of weapons!
We saw what 19 of them can do. Imagine millions who are well armed. We only ever had, at most, a half a million US troops in Iraq. A million of them here while most of our military is over there…not a good scenario.
Sir your false statistics do nothing more than prove the sterotyping that thanks to people like you people are blindly drawn to believe. If you took out EVERY single immigrant in the U.S.—No human being would be left inside. Go look at your family tree or something the only predicament I can point out gracefully is to ignorant people like yourself…oh and next time you pick up an orange or any other produce just think that without all the under minimum wage- your produce would be quadrupuling in price (without taking into account any possibilities of inflation problems in the future) :) Enjoy your day!
Whether there’s an immigration problem or not, the only people complaining are the low-skilled workers uneducated Americans that failed to take advantage of the opportunities available here. The only reason politicians care is because they get votes from people who are against immigration.